Top 5 Anal Sex Toys

Anal sex toys have never been more popular, and getting the fundamentals right, comfortable sizing, a flared or secure base, and easy cleanup, makes all the difference to how good they feel.

Whether you're just starting to explore anal play, looking for a reliable plug for everyday use, or want to add a proper cleansing step to your routine, the right pick depends on your experience level and what you're hoping to feel.

Ready to shop with confidence? Here are five of the best anal sex toys at Sex Toy Discount Warehouse right now.

What Makes a Great Anal Sex Toy?

A great anal toy should feel comfortable, have a secure flared base for safety, and suit your current experience level. Smaller and smoother is almost always the right place to start.

When shopping this category, look at material (body-safe silicone is the standard), taper and width, and whether the toy is designed for beginners or more experienced users. A tapered tip makes insertion easier and more comfortable.

Cleansing products, like douches, are also worth considering as part of a complete anal play routine, particularly for anyone exploring this category for the first time.

Browse the full anal sex toys range to compare sizes, styles and beginner-friendly options.

1. HiSmith 7.5" Slim Silicone Anal Dildo (KlicLok)

HiSmith 7.5" Slim Silicone Anal Dildo (KlicLok) is a standout pick, and its slim profile is exactly why. Designed with anal play specifically in mind, its slimmer width makes it approachable while the KlicLok base allows for machine attachment when you're ready.

That combination, comfortable sizing plus machine compatibility, makes it a smart choice whether you're using it by hand now or thinking about a machine down the track.

Why It Stands Out

It stands out as our top-selling anal toy overall, offering a genuinely slim, approachable size with the added flexibility of KlicLok machine compatibility.

Best For

Best for anal play beginners, shoppers wanting a slimmer option and anyone considering machine compatibility down the line.

2. Pink Medium Metallic Anal Plug

Pink Medium Metallic Anal Plug brings a completely different sensation to the category. Its smooth metal construction offers a firmer, cooler feel than silicone, along with a satisfying weight that many shoppers specifically look for.

Metal plugs are also incredibly easy to clean and maintain, adding to their appeal for anyone wanting a low-maintenance addition to their collection.

Why It Stands Out

It stands out because it offers a firmer, weightier metal sensation that silicone simply can't replicate, in an easy-care, medium-friendly size.

Best For

Best for shoppers wanting a firmer metal sensation, anyone who values easy cleanup and those moving beyond silicone for the first time.

3. HiSmith 7.1" Red Anal Dildo

HiSmith 7.1" Red Anal Dildo offers a comfortable, similarly sized alternative to our top pick, this time in a bold red finish. Its size sits right in that approachable, beginner-to-intermediate range that keeps selling well across the category.

For shoppers who want the reliability of a HiSmith anal toy without the machine attachment feature, this straightforward design delivers exactly that.

Why It Stands Out

It stands out because it delivers the same trusted HiSmith comfort and sizing in a bold, straightforward design without the added machine connector.

Best For

Best for shoppers wanting a comfortable, non-machine anal dildo and anyone who prefers a bold, confident colour choice.

4. HiSmith Silicone Smooth Beaded Anal Butt Plug Black (KlicLok)

HiSmith Silicone Smooth Beaded Anal Butt Plug Black (KlicLok) takes a different approach again, with a graduated, beaded design that builds sensation in stages rather than all at once. The smooth, rounded beads make for a gentler progression than a straight shaft.

Like other pieces in the HiSmith anal range, its KlicLok base means it can move from hand-held use to machine attachment whenever you're ready to make that jump.

Why It Stands Out

It stands out because its graduated, beaded design offers a gentler, staged sensation, with the same KlicLok flexibility found across the HiSmith range.

Best For

Best for shoppers who want a beaded, graduated sensation and anyone who values a gentler build-up over a straight shaft design.

5. CleanStream Premium One-Way Valve Anal Douche

CleanStream Premium One-Way Valve Anal Douche rounds out our top five as an essential, not a toy in the traditional sense, but a genuinely popular purchase for anyone serious about a clean, comfortable anal play routine.

Its one-way valve design makes filling and rinsing simple, and its consistent place in our best sellers shows just how many shoppers treat cleansing as a non-negotiable part of anal play.

Why It Stands Out

It stands out because it's the cleansing essential that consistently outsells plenty of toys, proving how seriously shoppers take proper anal hygiene.

Best For

Best for anyone building a complete anal play routine and shoppers who want simple, reliable cleansing before and after use.

How to Get the Best From Anal Sex Toys

Anal play works best when you go slowly, communicate clearly and always choose a toy with a flared or secure base designed specifically for anal use.

Apply plenty of lubricant before and during anal play. Unlike vaginal tissue, the anus doesn't self-lubricate, so generous, frequently reapplied lube is essential.

For anal play specifically, a thicker anal lubricant is often a smart choice, since it tends to stay in place longer than a thin, water-based formula.

Consider using an anal douche beforehand as part of a comfortable, confident routine.

After use, clean your toy with warm water and mild soap or a proper sex toy cleaner, then dry it fully before storage.

Which Anal Sex Toy Should You Choose?

Choose the HiSmith 7.5" Slim Silicone Anal Dildo if you want our top seller and a comfortable, machine-compatible size.

Choose the Pink Medium Metallic Anal Plug if you want a firmer, weightier metal sensation.

Choose the HiSmith 7.1" Red Anal Dildo if you want comparable comfort without the machine connector.

Choose the HiSmith Silicone Smooth Beaded Anal Butt Plug if you want a gentler, graduated sensation.

Choose the CleanStream Premium One-Way Valve Anal Douche if you want to build a complete, confident anal play routine.

Why These Anal Sex Toy Picks Stand Out

This top five spans a slim beginner-friendly dildo, a firmer metal plug, a bold alternative shape, a gentler beaded design and the cleansing essential that ties a whole routine together.

New to anal play? Start slim and add a douche to your routine. Ready for something different? Try metal or beads for a completely different sensation.

SALE FLOOR TRUTH: the best anal toy is the one sized right for where you're at, paired with proper lube and a clean, comfortable routine.

FAQ: Top 5 Anal Sex Toys

What is the best anal toy for beginners?

A slim, tapered silicone dildo or plug, like our top-selling HiSmith 7.5" Slim Silicone Anal Dildo, is usually the best starting point for beginners.

Do anal toys need lubricant?

Yes, always. The anus doesn't self-lubricate, so generous lubricant is essential for comfortable, safe anal play.

What lubricant is best for anal play?

A thicker anal-specific lubricant is often preferred, since it tends to stay in place longer than a standard water-based formula.

Should I use a douche before anal play?

Many people find a douche helps them feel cleaner and more confident before anal play, though it's a personal preference rather than a requirement.

Why does an anal toy need a flared base?

A flared or secure base prevents the toy from being fully inserted and lost, which is an essential safety feature for any anal toy.

How do I clean an anal toy?

Clean it before and after every use with warm water and mild soap or a proper toy cleaner, then dry thoroughly and store separately from other toys.

Are metal anal plugs comfortable?

Many people enjoy the firmer, weightier feel of metal plugs, though the sensation is different to silicone, so it's worth trying if you want variety.